Best Pizza in Long Island NY (Updated Fall 2023) - Pizza Oven Radar (2024)

I’ve spent a lot of time all over the world sampling various pies, so naturally, I was curious to see what Long Island had to offer. After eating my way through 12 different pizza places there, I can confidently say that there are plenty of delicious slices to be had on the island!

I’m here to tell you that it’s not just a place full of water parks and boardwalks; it’s also home to some seriously scrumptious pies. So if you’re looking for great pizza in Long Island, read on and let me guide you through my top picks – with a little bit of humor, too!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Acqua e Farina Pizzeria

The first thing I noticed upon entering the restaurant was the delicious aroma of freshly made pizza wafting through the air. Even before tasting their pies, I knew I was in for something special.

When my pizza arrived in front of me, my eyes widened. This wasn’t like any pizza I’d had before! The dough was light and fluffy with a slightly crispy outer edge, and it had the perfect amount of sauce and cheese on top.

I took a bite and couldn’t help but smile. The combination of flavors were so incredibly satisfying – salty tomato sauce combined with cheesy goodness that melted in my mouth with each bite. Plus, there were just enough toppings to add a little oomph without overpowering the delicate flavor of the crust.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Long Island NY, look no further than Acqua e Farina Pizzeria! You won’t be disappointed.

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Huntington!

#2 Saverio’s Authentic Pizza Napoletana

I’ve had many different types of pizza, from Chicago deep-dish to thin Italian slices and it’s always a struggle to decide which one is the best. But after tasting Saverio’s Authentic Pizza Napoletana, I could tell this was something special.

The crust was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of crunch. The topping selection was phenomenal and there was something for everyone. From fresh vegetables to delicious meats – all cooked to perfection. And the cheese! Oh, the cheese! It melted in my mouth and gave me a flavor explosion that I’ll never forget!

Overall, my experience at Saverio’s Authentic Pizza Napoletana was fantastic. Not only did they have some of the best pizza in Long Island NY, but they also had friendly staff and a great atmosphere. If you’re ever looking for top-notch pizza, look no further than Saverio’s Authentic Pizza Napoletana!

#3 Mozzafiato Pizzeria

I recently visited this establishment and was pleasantly surprised by the delightful atmosphere. The customer service was top-notch and the wait staff was friendly and attentive.

When it came to the food, it lived up to its reputation. The pizza dough was thick yet light and airy, resulting in a perfectly crisp crust. The fresh ingredients were carefully selected to create unique flavor combinations that left me wanting more!

The highlight of my experience, however, was the incredible variety of topping options they had available. From classic choices like pepperoni and sausage to more adventurous toppings like onions, peppers, mushrooms and olives, each bite was a culinary masterpiece.

All in all, Mozzafiato Pizzeria is definitely worth visiting if you’re looking for the best pizza in Long Island NY. I highly recommend it!

#4 Colosseo Pizza

When I walked in the door, I was met with the heavenly scent of cheese and tomato – a classic combination that I knew would be perfect for my first slice.

Their crust is wonderfully thin yet thick enough to hold the generous amounts of toppings they offer. It’s cooked to perfection on a hot stone oven, making it one of the best crusts I’ve had in a while.

I’m not exaggerating when I say that the sauce at Colosseo Pizza tastes like it was made by Italian grandmothers – it’s packed full of flavour and fragrant herbs. The cheese was well balanced with just the right amount of saltiness and sweetness. And as for the toppings? Let’s just say my tummy was pretty happy after wolfing down my giant slice!

From start to finish, Colosseo Pizza prides itself on quality ingredients and traditional Italian recipes, giving customers an unforgettable experience every time. As if their pizza wasn’t enough, they have amazing starters and pastas too!

If you’re searching for New York-style pizza but don’t want to venture into Manhattan, you simply have to visit Colosseo Pizza – you won’t regret it!

#5 The Pie at Salvatore’s

I’m not sure where Salvatore’s gets its ingredients, but let me tell you, they make a mean pie. The crust is thin and flavorful, with a slight crunch that adds to the overall experience. The sauce is perfectly seasoned and blended with an Italian-inspired flair, while the cheese is light and fluffy. And the toppings! If I had to pick one of my favorites it would definitely have to be their classic pepperoni – loads of flavor but not too greasy or salty.

What sets this place apart from the rest is their attitude: friendly faces greet you at the door and there’s never any pressure to hurry up your order. It’s like a cozy family kitchen – it’s that kind of warmth that really makes all the difference.

All in all, The Pie at Salvatore’s is definitely worth trying out if you’re ever in the Long Island area and looking for some of the best pizza around. Bon Appetit!

#6 Salvatore’s

From the moment I walked in the door, I knew I was onto something special. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with checkered tablecloths and cozy lighting.

The menu was filled with all kinds of amazing options that had me salivating at first glance. Everything from classic Margheritas to bolder creations like garlic shrimp pizzas, it was clear that this place had something for everyone.

But it was the pizza itself that won me over in the end. When my slice arrived, it was unbelievably delicious! The dough was light and airy, crisp on the outside but still tender and fluffy inside. The sauce was delicate yet full of flavor, and the cheese melted perfectly across each bite. With a sprinkling of herbs on top, this pizza really hit all the right notes.

I’m so glad I got to experience Salvatore’s pizza – it’s definitely some of the best pizza in Long Island NY! If you’re ever in town, do yourself a favor and give them a try – you’ll be glad you did!

#7 Ciro’s Pizza

I had the pleasure of visiting Ciro’s Pizza recently and the experience was extraordinary! With a family owned atmosphere, I felt welcomed from the second I stepped in the door. The staff was extremely friendly and accommodating, which is quite rare for me as a food critic.

The highlight of my visit was definitely their pizza. It was cooked to perfection with its golden-brown crust, bubbly cheese, and flavorful toppings. I have to admit, it reminded me of some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted traveling abroad!

To top off my experience, the prices at Ciro’s Pizza are super reasonable. You get more quality than what you pay for – it’s almost like getting a pizza without breaking your budget!

If you’re ever near Long Island NY and looking for great pizza at an affordable price, Ciro’s Pizza is definitely your spot! Highly recommended.

#8 Talluci’s Pizzeria

The delicious crust is always perfectly cooked, with just the right amount of char and crunch. The toppings are always fresh and flavorful, and the sauces are bold and savory. Every time I visit Talluci’s, I’m blown away by how perfectly balanced their pizzas are.

What sets this establishment apart from others is their attention to detail. Not only do they use high-quality ingredients in all of their dishes, but each pizza is made with love and care that you can taste in every bite!

If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience on Long Island NY, then Talluci’s Pizzeria should be at the top of your list!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Deer Park!

#9 Miseno Pizza

I must say, the atmosphere in Miseno Pizza is great – it feels like you’ve stepped into an Italian pizzeria. The staff was friendly, and the pizza was piping hot and fresh out of the oven.

The crust was perfectly done with a nice crunchy outer layer that gave way to a soft and chewy center. The sauce was tangy with just the right amount of sweetness that had me licking my lips! To top it off, there were plenty of toppings to choose from. From veggies to sausage to pepperoni, there’s something for everyone.

Overall, I give Miseno Pizza two thumbs up for their delicious pizza and excellent service! If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Long Island NY, be sure to stop by Miseno Pizza!

#10 Manetta’s

I had heard from friends and family that Manetta’s was the place to be for the best pizza in town, so I decided to check it out for myself. Upon entering, I was still skeptical about what was in store… until I tasted their Neapolitan-style pizzas!

The thin crust was cooked perfectly – not too thin or too thick. The sauce had a nice balance of sweet and savoury flavour that really stood out. It also had a great amount of cheese on top, but not too much either.

What I enjoyed just as much as the pizza was the atmosphere of Manetta’s. The walls were adorned with old photos of Italy and a sense of warmth and hospitality filled the air. On top of that, the service was excellent – they treated me like family!

If you’re looking for some truly amazing pizza in Long Island NY, then Manettas is definitely your spot. Believe me – you won’t be disappointed!

#11 Ancona Pizzeria & Heroes

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it a great place for friends, family, and even solo dining. The staff is friendly and professional, and you can tell that they really care about their customers.

The pizza itself is out of this world! From the thin crust to the gooey cheese and the variety of toppings available — there’s something for everyone to enjoy. I’m particularly fond of their signature pie: The Ancona Special. It’s a mix of pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers, and extra cheese — an absolute must-try.

To top it all off, the prices are very reasonable here so you don’t have to break the bank to get a delicious slice! All in all, I highly recommend Ancona Pizzeria & Heroes if you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza in Long Island NY!

#12 Branchinelli’s Pizza & Restaurant

I had the pleasure of visiting Branchinelli’s recently, and boy was I in for a treat. As soon as I walked in the door, I knew this would be an unforgettable experience. The smell of fresh, delicious pizza wafted through the air. The entire staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating.

The pizza at Branchinelli’s was unlike anything I’ve ever experienced before. It was light, airy, and cooked to perfection with just the right amount of cheese and toppings. Every bite melted in my mouth and made me forget that I’m a food critic!

Not only that but the prices are extremely reasonable; you can’t beat getting great pizza for such a low cost. All in all, my experience at Branchinelli’s was top-notch and far exceeded my expectations. If you ever have a hankering for some really good pizza in Long Island NY, don’t hesitate to pay them a visit – you won’t regret it!